Tips for
Small Group Study


1. Use Death by Suburb as an 8-week study on the spiritual disciplines.

2. Each week study one of the 8 chapters that explain the suburban toxins and the spiritual practices that counter them.

3. Download the free discussion guide for a list of questions to guide the discussion for each chapter.

4. Download Dave's Favorite Writers for additional resources on Christian spirituality.

5. Sign up with your email address to receive regular blog updates by the author.

6. Add your suburban story of The Thicker Life to the blog.

Subscribe to receive updates:
first name last name e-mail
   

If It Makes You Happy, Then Why Are You So Sad?

Post a response

Boys from North Dakota don’t go to hair salons, even if they now live in the Chicago suburbs. It’s not manly.

However, there are exceptions, like when you start to bald. You need more than a butcher for a barber. You need someone (a young woman, preferably) who can finesse your hair to lay strategically.

Okay, so I go to a hair salon. And the other day, my salonist told me that she and her boyfriend were buying their first house.

I congratulated her and said, “You’ve got to be excited—your first home together!”

But she hedged: “Well, it’s way out in Plainfield. It’s only a three bedroom in one of those subdivisions. It’s small. We’re going to do the sweat equity thing, where you don’t have to pay as much. You do the painting, you put in the sod. But at least I get to choose the color of the linoleum.”

In what was supposed to be a time of joy, she couldn’t even taste the moment. All she could think about was that the house wasn’t as nice as she had hoped and, in some sense, she was already looking to the time when she and her boyfriend could move up to the next level of house.

I felt sad for her. The suburbs seem to create an environment of chronic discontent. We’re never happy, because what we acquire is never exactly what we envisioned.

4 Responses to “If It Makes You Happy, Then Why Are You So Sad?”

  1. Jim Anderson Says:

    …And don’t you come away from an encounter like that with the “salonist”, wishing you had found some way to challenge the acceptedness of just “living together”?

  2. Administrator Says:

    Actually, she was very nervous about that. I asked her when she was going to get married, and she said, “Well, I hope soon.” She was very aware that the sequence was wrong.

    I tried to do the old Dr. Phil thing, to ask, “How’s that working for you?”

    Great point!

  3. Michael Ryan Says:

    Dave, first off, I’m sitting here cracking up that you go to the salon…give me a minute…whoo…alright, I’m done laughing and I can move on.

    I’m wondering what satisfaction she would have received if she would have had sod installed, painted walls, and all of the nuances of the house of her dreams. Sod doesn’t do anything for a person. Paint doesn’t either. (Although, the psychological critic might argue that colors affect moods…irrelevant.) What I’m getting at–and I think you were too–is that the trendy, tidy, professional, shiek, hip, yuppie material does nothing more for its owner than its generic competitors. I take that back. It does create increased responsibility and a heightened sense of awareness of the safety (or lack thereof) of the material.

    What this young lady doesn’t realize, I presume, is that she wants those things, not for herself, but for others. And it is not so that others might benefit from these things, but so that others will see the “true” status of who she is. This creates, again, new responsibility to maintain, upkeep and upgrade the material. It invokes either a response of jealousy, equality or superiority of other like-minded observers. If it is jealousy, she feels superior, but has to protect her material. If it is equality, then she feels mediocre. If it is superiority, then the inverse reaction is that she feels inferior. It’s a lose-lose-lose.

    Jesus’ view of money/material in Scripture has been like a huge mallet, hitting me over and over again since I entered seminary. I feel inhibited to wear the clothes from my pre-seminary days when I go out, because I may be mistaken as “wealthy.” That is not a good thing to be mistaken as in some neighborhoods. But those observe us are judging us. The litmus test of who we are is, sadly, our material. How our culture has bewitched us!

    Talk about a toxin! We are what we wear. We are what we drive. We are where we live and what we live in. We are what church we attend. We are what school district our kids are in. On and on it goes…like me on this blog.

  4. Karen O'Keeffe Says:

    Dave Ramsey (Christian radio host and money “guru”) talks about how young couples get married and society expects them to live at the same quality of life level that their parents took 30 years to achieve. It’s so true. A big house, new furniture, a fancy car….and all of the debt that goes with it. It is so difficult to turn our perspectives around – to be grateful for whatever God has provided us with, not desirous of what He has not. That mind set makes us “weird”, particularly way out here in the suburbs.

Leave a Reply


Advance Praise for
Death by Suburb


"Death by Suburb ... addresses and overcomes the split in our religion, our lifestyles, and even our consciousness."
—Fr. Richard Rohr, O.F.M., author of Everything Belongs: The Gift of Contemplative Prayer

"With a compassion born of his own experiences of suburban unreality and dysfunction, Goetz effectively evokes a thicker sense of our social and religious worlds."
—Leigh Schmidt, Princeton University, author of Restless Souls: The Making of American Spirituality

"Goetz sees the parched lives, the truncated spirits beneath the suburban bliss, and the grace too. In his gracious eyes suburbia begins to look like an outbreak of the Kingdom of God."
—William H. Willimon, author of Sinning Like a Christian